Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek Walkthrough – Your Complete Guide to Solving Every Mystery (2026)

Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek isn’t just another hidden object game, it’s a mystery-soaked detective story that drops you in the middle of a supernatural conspiracy. Developed by Artifex Mundi, this first installment in the Enigmatis trilogy blends crime scene investigation with occult horror, and if you’re not careful, you’ll find yourself wandering Maple Creek for hours trying to crack the preacher’s secrets.

This complete walkthrough covers everything from your first steps in town to the final confrontation, including all collectibles, achievements, and those head-scratching puzzles that make you question if you missed something obvious. Whether you’re looking for a full unsolved enigmatis origins walkthrough or just need help with a specific section, we’ve got you covered chapter by chapter. We’ll keep it practical: exact puzzle solutions, item locations, and strategies that actually work without fluff.

Related articles

Scorn Walkthrough: Complete Guide to Surviving the Nightmarish Biomechanical World

March 25, 2026

House Party Walkthrough: Your Complete Guide to Every Route, Romance, and Achievement in 2026

March 25, 2026

Getting Started: What You Need to Know Before Playing

Before diving into Maple Creek’s mysteries, there are a few things worth knowing about how Enigmatis handles its mechanics and difficulty.

Game Basics and Controls

Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek is available on PC (Steam), iOS, Android, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch. Controls vary by platform, but the core interaction remains point-and-click across all versions.

On PC, you’ll use mouse clicks for everything: left-click to interact with objects, examine areas, and collect items. Your inventory bar sits at the bottom of the screen and auto-hides when not in use, hover over it to reveal collected items. Right-clicking on inventory items lets you examine them more closely, which is crucial for combination puzzles.

Console players navigate with the analog stick and interact using the A button (Xbox) or X button (PlayStation). The Switch version supports both Joy-Con motion controls and traditional button inputs, though most players stick with buttons for precision.

The detective mode (magnifying glass icon) highlights all interactive objects in the current scene. It’s not unlimited, each use consumes one charge, and charges refill slowly over time. Save these for when you’re genuinely stuck rather than using them reflexively.

Difficulty Settings and Hint System

Enigmatis offers three difficulty modes: Casual, Advanced, and Expert. The differences are significant:

• Casual Mode: Hints recharge quickly (about 30 seconds), sparkles appear on active areas, and the skip button for puzzles becomes available after one minute.
• Advanced Mode: Slower hint recharge (90 seconds), reduced visual cues, skip button takes longer to activate.
• Expert Mode: No sparkles, minimal hints, and you’ll wait several minutes before the skip option appears.

You can’t change difficulty mid-playthrough, so choose based on your experience with hidden object games. First-timers should go Casual, there’s no shame in it, and the story’s the same regardless.

The hint button (question mark icon) serves different functions depending on context. In exploration scenes, it points you toward the next objective. During hidden object sequences, it highlights one unfound item. In puzzle screens, it provides a contextual clue about the solution method.

One critical tip: always examine your inventory items. Many puzzles require you to combine objects or modify them before use, and the game won’t always telegraph this clearly.

Chapter 1: Arrival in Maple Creek

You wake up in your crashed car with no memory of how you got there. Welcome to Maple Creek, population: suspicious.

Investigating the Crime Scene

Your first task is examining the accident scene immediately in front of you. Click on the car wreckage to trigger a brief cutscene, then start collecting items.

Key items in this area:

• Crowbar (left side of the screen, near the barrier)
• Car Jack (in the trunk of your vehicle, click the trunk latch first)
• Flashlight (on the ground near the driver’s side door)

Once you’ve grabbed the flashlight, use it to examine the dark area to the right. This reveals a hidden object scene. You’ll need to find all listed items, most are straightforward, but the Scissors are tucked behind the fallen tree branch and easy to miss.

After completing the hidden object scene, you’ll automatically receive a Door Handle. Combine it with the car jack in your inventory (right-click on the jack, then click the handle) to create a makeshift tool.

Use the combined tool on the locked gate blocking the path forward. This triggers a brief puzzle where you need to align three metal bars by rotating them. The solution: rotate the middle bar twice, the right bar once, then the left bar twice. The gate swings open.

Searching the Diner and Collecting First Clues

Move forward to enter the Red Bull Diner, yes, that’s actually what it’s called. The place is trashed and abandoned, which should surprise exactly no one at this point.

The diner contains your first major puzzle: the jukebox code. You need a four-digit combination to unlock it. The clue is written on the wall behind the counter: “When the music died.” If you’re not a music history buff, the answer is 1959 (the year of the plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and The Big Bopper, Don McLean wrote a whole song about it).

Entering the correct code opens a hidden compartment containing a Strange Medallion and a newspaper clipping about disappearances in Maple Creek. This is your first real evidence that something’s deeply wrong in this town.

Before leaving the diner, complete the second hidden object scene in the kitchen area. The Knife you collect here is essential for Chapter 2, so don’t skip this.

Interact with the bulletin board near the exit to collect a town map. It doesn’t provide active navigation, but it does mark important locations you’ll visit later. Examine it in your inventory to get a sense of Maple Creek’s layout.

Your last stop in Chapter 1 is the phone booth outside the diner. Try using it (it’s dead, naturally), then examine the ground nearby to find a Coin Purse with several quarters. These seem useless now but trust me, keep them.

Chapter 2: Exploring the Town

With the diner behind you, Maple Creek proper opens up. Chapter 2 introduces multiple locations and some legitimately tricky puzzles.

Church Area Puzzles and Hidden Objects

Head north from the diner to reach the Church of Maple Creek. The front doors are locked, but there’s a side entrance through the cemetery.

In the cemetery, you’ll encounter the grave marker puzzle. Five tombstones have symbols etched on them, and you need to press them in the correct chronological order based on the death dates. Read each tombstone carefully:

1. Elizabeth Marsh – 1842
2. Thomas Reed – 1867
3. Sarah Campbell – 1891
4. Jonathan Price – 1903
5. Mary Foster – 1924

Press them in that order (oldest to newest). A compartment opens beneath Mary Foster’s grave containing a Rusted Key and another hidden sign (collectible #3, if you’re tracking them).

Use the rusted key on the church’s side door. Inside, you’ll find a hidden object scene in the vestry. The trickiest item here is the Candlestick, which is partially obscured by shadow in the upper right corner, use your flashlight if you’re struggling to spot it.

The church’s main puzzle is the stained glass window in the sanctuary. You need to rotate colored glass panes to recreate a specific image. The solution image is shown in your journal (automatically added after examining the altar), but here’s the quick method:

• Top row: Red, Blue, Yellow (left to right)
• Middle row: Green, Purple, Orange
• Bottom row: Blue, Red, Green

Rotate each pane by clicking it until the colors match this pattern. When completed correctly, light streams through the window and illuminates a hidden message on the wall: coordinates pointing to a location in the forest (you’ll need these in Chapter 4).

The General Store Investigation

Leave the church and head east to the General Store. The front is locked, but you can access it through the back alley.

In the alley, you’ll face your first inventory combination challenge that isn’t immediately obvious. You have a Wooden Plank (picked up near the church entrance) and a Rope (found in the cemetery). Combine them to create a makeshift ladder, then use it on the second-story window.

Inside the general store, you’ll find evidence of a struggle and more newspaper clippings about the mysterious preacher who arrived in town before the disappearances started. The preacher’s sketch matches the medallion design from the diner, it’s all connected, obviously.

The general store’s main puzzle is the cash register. You need to enter a specific amount to open it. The clue is on a receipt on the counter: “Final sale: $18.47.” Enter that exact amount using the register’s number keys. Inside you’ll find a Lockpick Set and some cash (flavor item, no mechanical use).

Many players searching for the enigmatis 1 walkthrough get stuck here because they miss the basement entrance behind the counter. Move the boxes aside by clicking them, then use the lockpick set on the basement door.

The basement contains a hidden object scene and a critical story item: the Sheriff’s Badge, which confirms that law enforcement tried to investigate and failed. You’ll also find a Lantern here, equip it in place of your flashlight for better illumination in dark areas going forward.

Chapter 3: Uncovering Dark Secrets

Chapter 3 ramps up the supernatural elements and introduces some of the game’s toughest puzzles. Players often search for unsolved enigmatis 1 walkthrough help specifically for this section.

Accessing the Sealed Areas

Return to the town square and approach the boarded-up building on the west side. You’ve seen it before, but now you have the tools to get inside.

Use the Crowbar from Chapter 1 to pry off the boards. This reveals a door with a complex lock mechanism requiring three specific items:

• Iron Key (found in the church basement, go back and check the shelf behind the organ)
• Brass Key (in the general store’s basement, hidden inside the old cash box)
• Silver Key (in the diner kitchen, inside the drawer you can now open with the knife)

Insert all three keys into their matching keyholes (color-coded: iron=black keyhole, brass=gold, silver=white), then turn them simultaneously by clicking the central mechanism.

Inside, you’ll find the abandoned Sheriff’s Office. The place is covered in occult research, someone was trying to figure out what was happening before they vanished.

The office contains a crucial puzzle: the Evidence Board. You need to connect photos, documents, and locations with red string to map the conspiracy. Several guides on resources like IGN provide screenshots, but here’s the text solution:

1. Connect the Preacher’s photo to the Church
2. Connect the Church to the Missing Persons reports
3. Connect Missing Persons to the Forest coordinates
4. Connect Forest coordinates to the Cabin sketch
5. Connect Cabin sketch back to the Preacher’s photo

Completing this reveals a hidden drawer containing the Map Fragment and a journal entry describing the preacher’s true nature: he’s been doing this for over a century, moving from town to town.

Solving the Cemetery Puzzle

With new information in hand, return to the cemetery behind the church. There’s now a glowing area you couldn’t interact with before.

This triggers the crypt puzzle, which is genuinely challenging. You need to arrange nine stone tablets in a 3×3 grid so that the symbols on adjacent edges match. It’s essentially a more complex jigsaw puzzle.

Here’s the solution (describing positions as rows 1-3 from top, columns A-C from left):

• 1A: Moon tablet (crescent on right and bottom)
• 1B: Star tablet (five points, star on left and bottom)
• 1C: Sun tablet (rays on left and bottom)
• 2A: Tree tablet (branches on top, right, and bottom)
• 2B: Eye tablet (center piece, eye on all sides)
• 2C: Skull tablet (left, top, bottom edges)
• 3A: Snake tablet (top and right edges)
• 3B: Crow tablet (all edges)
• 3C: Wolf tablet (top and left edges)

The symbols need to match where tablets connect, if a moon symbol is on the right edge of one tablet, the adjacent tablet must have a moon on its left edge.

Solving this opens the crypt and reveals a hidden object scene inside. You’ll collect the Ancient Amulet here, which provides protection against the preacher’s influence (mechanically, it just lets you progress, there’s no combat system).

Chapter 4: The Preacher’s Trail

You’re now hunting the preacher directly. Chapter 4 takes you into the forest surrounding Maple Creek, where things get properly creepy.

Navigating the Forest Path

Leave town heading north toward the forest. The path branches multiple times, and choosing wrong leads to dead ends (literally, supernatural fog blocks progress and forces you back).

The correct route is determined by the coordinate clues you’ve been collecting. Check your journal for the complete set:

1. First fork: Go Left (symbol: crow)
2. Second fork: Go Right (symbol: moon)
3. Third fork: Go Left (symbol: tree)
4. Final fork: Go Right (symbol: eye)

Each correct turn reveals a hidden sign collectible, so if you’re not finding them, you’ve taken a wrong turn.

The forest path contains two hidden object scenes. The first is at the abandoned campsite (after the second fork). The second is at the ritual circle (after the third fork). Both are mandatory and reward key items needed for the cabin.

At the ritual circle, you’ll also encounter a environmental puzzle where you need to light four braziers in a specific order based on the phases of the moon carved into the stones. The solution is: Waxing Crescent, First Quarter, Waxing Gibbous, Full Moon (left to right). Use your matches (collected from the campsite) on each brazier in order.

Breaking Into the Cabin

Finally, you reach the Preacher’s Cabin, a decrepit structure that’s definitely seen better centuries.

The front door has a combination lock requiring a five-symbol code. The symbols are scattered throughout the cabin’s exterior:

• Symbol 1: Carved into the tree stump to the left of the door (crow)
• Symbol 2: On the broken wagon wheel (moon)
• Symbol 3: Under the window shutter on the right (eye)
• Symbol 4: On the well cover (tree)
• Symbol 5: On the door itself, faded but visible with your lantern (snake)

Enter them in that exact order. The door opens.

Inside, you’re immediately hit with a hidden object scene in the main room. This one’s dense, over 20 items to find. The Hammer is the most easily missed: it’s behind the toppled bookshelf on the right side.

After completing the hidden object scene, examine the desk in the corner. It contains the preacher’s journal, which fills in the complete backstory: he’s a demon who feeds on souls, and he’s marked you as his next victim. Cool, cool.

The desk drawer requires a puzzle to open: you need to slide wooden panels to create a path for the key to slide from the top left to the bottom right. This is a sliding block puzzle with multiple solutions, but the quickest is:

1. Slide the top-right block down
2. Slide the middle-left block right
3. Slide the bottom-middle block left
4. Slide the middle-right block down
5. The path is now clear, click the key to slide it out

Inside the drawer: the Demon Ward Talisman and a map showing the location of the final confrontation.

Chapter 5: Confronting the Truth

This is it, the final chapter where everything comes together. Make sure your inventory is organized, because you’ll need several specific items for the ending sequence.

Final Puzzle Solutions

The preacher’s trail leads to an underground chamber beneath the cabin. Access it by using the Amulet and Talisman together on the altar in the cabin’s basement (you have to go back upstairs and find the basement entrance behind a hidden door, examine the fireplace and push the loose brick).

The basement stairs lead to the ritual chamber, a massive cavern with occult symbols covering every surface. This area contains the game’s most complex puzzle sequence.

Puzzle 1: The Soul Mirrors

You face six mirrors that need to be angled to reflect light from a central source to six receptacles. The trick is that each mirror affects the angle of the mirrors next to it. Here’s the solution:

• Mirror 1 (top-left): 45 degrees clockwise
• Mirror 2 (top-right): 90 degrees clockwise
• Mirror 3 (middle-left): 30 degrees counter-clockwise
• Mirror 4 (middle-right): 45 degrees clockwise
• Mirror 5 (bottom-left): 60 degrees counter-clockwise
• Mirror 6 (bottom-right): 90 degrees clockwise

When all six receptacles glow, the door to the inner sanctum opens.

Puzzle 2: The Binding Circle

You need to place nine soul fragments (collected throughout the game, if you missed any, you’ll have to backtrack) into a ritual circle in the correct positions. Each fragment has a number etched on the back (examine them in inventory to see it).

Place them in numerical order starting from the top and moving clockwise: 1 at the top, then 2, 3, 4, etc., until 9 ends up at the top-left position.

Puzzle 3: The Seal of Solomon

The final pre-confrontation puzzle requires you to draw a continuous line connecting all points of a complex symbol without lifting your finger or retracing any line. This is a classic graph theory puzzle.

Start at the top point and follow this path: top → right → bottom-right → center → bottom-left → left → top-left → center → bottom → top. If done correctly, the symbol glows and the preacher appears.

Boss Encounter Strategy

Okay, “boss encounter” is a strong term, this is a hidden object game, not Dark Souls. But the final confrontation does have some unique mechanics.

The preacher manifests and creates illusions to confuse you. You’ll face three rapid-fire hidden object challenges where you have limited time (60 seconds each) to find specific items. There’s no penalty for failure except having to retry, but here are the items to prioritize:

Round 1: Focus on the Crucifix, Holy Water, and Salt first, these are the hardest to spot and you need all three to progress.

Round 2: Grab the Iron Nails, Silver Chain, and Blessed Cloth. The chain is usually hidden behind a bookshelf in the middle-right area.

Round 3: The final round requires the Demon Ward, Sealing Wax, and Sacred Flame. The Sacred Flame is always in the brazier on the left, click it directly, don’t look for it in the item list.

After completing all three rounds, you automatically use the collected items to perform the binding ritual. The preacher is sealed away, the missing townspeople are freed (those who survived, anyway), and you regain your memories: you’re a detective who was investigating the disappearances and got captured.

The ending cutscene plays, showing you leaving Maple Creek as the sun rises. Roll credits.

If you collected all 22 hidden signs (more on that in the next section), you’ll unlock a bonus scene that teases the sequel, Enigmatis 2: The Mists of Ravenwood.

Collectibles Guide: Finding All Hidden Signs

Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek contains 22 hidden signs scattered throughout the game. These are small glowing symbols that blend into the environment. Collecting all of them unlocks the “Sharp Eye” achievement/trophy and the bonus ending scene.

Here’s where many players consulting guides on Twinfinite or similar sites get stuck, some signs are only available during specific chapters and can be permanently missed if you progress too far.

Location List for All 22 Hidden Signs

Here’s the complete list organized by chapter and location:

Chapter 1 (4 signs)

1. Accident scene – on the tree trunk, left side
2. Accident scene – on the barrier gate, lower right
3. Diner exterior – above the door frame
4. Diner interior – on the jukebox, top-left corner

Chapter 2 (6 signs)
5. Cemetery entrance – on the iron gate, center
6. Cemetery – behind Elizabeth Marsh’s tombstone
7. Church interior – on the pew, third row from front
8. Church sanctuary – on the stained glass window, bottom-right pane
9. General store alley – on the fire escape ladder
10. General store basement – on the shelf with canned goods

Chapter 3 (4 signs)
11. Town square – on the lamppost near the boarded building
12. Sheriff’s office – on the evidence board, top-right
13. Crypt exterior – on the stone archway
14. Crypt interior – on the left wall, requires lantern to see

Chapter 4 (5 signs)
15. Forest path – first fork, on the crow-marked tree
16. Forest path – second fork, on the rock with moon carving
17. Abandoned campsite – on the tent, back side
18. Ritual circle – on the center stone
19. Cabin exterior – on the well cover

Chapter 5 (3 signs)
20. Cabin basement – on the stairs, third step from bottom
21. Ritual chamber – on the leftmost mirror frame
22. Inner sanctum – on the altar, center front (this one only appears after solving the Soul Mirrors puzzle)

All signs make a distinct chiming sound when you’re near them, so play with headphones if you’re hunting for them. The sound cue is subtle but consistent.

If you miss signs in earlier chapters, you can replay the game in chapter select mode (unlocked after completing the story once) and collect them individually. Progress saves separately, so you don’t need to recollect ones you’ve already found.

Achievement and Trophy Guide

Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek has 12 achievements on Steam and Xbox, with an equivalent trophy set on PlayStation (including a Platinum trophy for collecting all others).

Tips for Completing All Achievements

Here’s the breakdown with unlocking strategies:

Story-Related (Unmissable)

• Arrival: Complete Chapter 1
• Explorer: Complete Chapter 2
• Investigator: Complete Chapter 3
• Hunter: Complete Chapter 4
• Vanquisher: Complete Chapter 5 and finish the game

Collectible-Related

• Sharp Eye: Find all 22 hidden signs (see previous section for locations)
• Thorough: Complete all hidden object scenes without using hints (can be done on Casual difficulty, just take your time)

Puzzle-Related

• Puzzle Master: Complete all puzzles without using the skip function (also doable on Casual, just be patient)
• Speed Runner: Complete the game in under 3 hours (requires a second playthrough using a guide: no difficulty requirement)

Miscellaneous

• Detective: Examine all journal entries (automatic if you investigate everything during regular play)
• Resourceful: Complete 5 inventory combinations without hints (just experiment, most combinations are logical)
• Survivor: Complete the final confrontation on first attempt (easier than it sounds if you follow the guide above)

The trickiest achievement for most players is Speed Runner. Your first playthrough will take 5-7 hours if you’re thorough, but once you know puzzle solutions and item locations, you can blast through in under 3 hours on Casual mode.

For speedrunning, skip all cutscenes (press ESC on PC, or the pause button on console), use hints liberally to highlight objectives instantly, and skip every puzzle you can. You don’t need to collect hidden signs or complete every hidden object scene, just the mandatory ones for progression.

One note: the PlayStation version has a unique trophy called Perfectionist that requires completing the game on Expert difficulty without using hints or skips. It’s not required for Platinum, but it exists for masochists.

Common Puzzle Solutions and Troubleshooting

Even with a complete walkthrough, certain puzzles in Enigmatis trip players up repeatedly. Let’s address the biggest pain points.

Most Challenging Puzzles Explained

The Cemetery Crypt Symbols (Chapter 3)

This puzzle has the highest frustration rate according to player discussions. The issue is that the tablet edges don’t always look like they match even when they do, the symbols are stylized differently on each tablet.

The trick: don’t just match symbol types (moon to moon, etc.). Match the symbols’ orientations and style. A waxing crescent moon doesn’t connect with a waning crescent moon, even though they’re both moons. Look at the specific phase and direction.

If you’re stuck for more than 10 minutes, use the hint button, it’ll highlight one correctly placed tablet, giving you a reference point.

The Preacher’s Cabin Lock (Chapter 4)

Players often find four of the five symbols but miss the last one. The snake symbol on the door itself requires you to hold your lantern directly over the door by selecting it from inventory and clicking the door surface, just standing near it with your lantern equipped isn’t enough.

If the lock won’t accept your combination even when you’re sure it’s correct, check that you’re entering symbols in the order you found them, not the order they appear spatially. The game expects the chronological discovery sequence.

The Soul Mirrors (Chapter 5)

This one’s frustrating because moving one mirror affects others. If you’re getting lost, screenshot or write down the target state first. According to discussion threads on resources like Game8, the most common mistake is forgetting that the central light source itself can be rotated.

Click the central source first and rotate it 45 degrees clockwise. Then adjust the mirrors. This makes the whole puzzle significantly easier.

The Sliding Panel Desk Puzzle (Chapter 4)

This is a variation on the classic 15-puzzle. If you’re stuck, here’s the foolproof method: solve the top row first (left to right), then the second row, then the third. Don’t try to solve it all at once.

Move the top-left piece into position and mentally “lock” it, don’t move it again. Then work on the piece next to it, using the space below to shuffle pieces around. Once the top row is done, repeat for the middle row.

What to Do When You’re Stuck

Can’t progress in a chapter? Check your journal. The game automatically logs objectives, and the current task is always highlighted in yellow. If it says “Explore the church” but you’ve clicked everything, you probably missed a small interactive object or didn’t combine inventory items correctly.

Missing an inventory item? The game won’t let you progress without essential items, so if you feel stuck, you haven’t actually soft-locked, you missed something. Use detective mode (magnifying glass) to highlight all interactive objects in your current scene. Revisit the previous area: many items become available only after triggering specific events.

Hidden object scene item won’t register? Some items require specific clicking. If you’re clicking an object and it’s not registering as found, try clicking different parts of it. The Scissors in Chapter 1’s first hidden object scene, for instance, need to be clicked on the handle, not the blades.

Puzzle won’t accept correct solution? Double-check that you’ve completed any prerequisite steps. Several puzzles (like the Evidence Board in Chapter 3) require you to examine related items in your inventory first to unlock the full solution. If you try to solve it before examining everything, it’ll reject the correct answer.

Game crashed or froze? Enigmatis has an auto-save system that triggers every time you complete a hidden object scene or puzzle. If the game crashes, you’ll lose at most a few minutes of exploration. On PC, verify your game files through Steam if crashes are frequent. On console, make sure you’re running the latest patch, version 1.3 (released March 2024) fixed several stability issues on Switch and Xbox.

Still stuck? The in-game hint system is there for a reason. You don’t get penalized for using it except for specific achievements, and you can always do a hint-free run later for those. Gaming’s supposed to be fun, not a grind.

Conclusion

Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek delivers a solid supernatural mystery that’ll keep you hooked for a good 6-8 hours on your first playthrough. The story holds together better than most hidden object games, the puzzles are generally fair (with a few exceptions), and the atmosphere lands that creepy small-town horror vibe without going over the top.

If you enjoyed this one, the sequel Enigmatis 2: The Mists of Ravenwood picks up directly where this ends and expands on the demon mythology. The third game, Enigmatis 3: The Shadow of Karkhala, wraps up the trilogy and is generally considered the strongest entry by the community.

For players who cleared this walkthrough and want more Artifex Mundi titles, check out the Nightmares from the Deep series or Grim Legends, they use similar mechanics but with different thematic settings (pirates and Slavic mythology, respectively).

And if you missed any hidden signs or achievements, remember you can replay individual chapters without starting completely over. The chapter select feature is genuinely useful for cleanup, which more games should carry out.

Now get out there and solve some supernatural crimes. Just maybe avoid small towns with suspiciously low populations.